Trust on the Toll Road
A good friend of mine, Bob, recently lost his mother. Following the funeral, disheveled and still in mourning he took to the road to return to Boston. Approaching the tolls at the New York Thruway, he tried to slow down and discovered he had no brakes.
In the split second Bob had to choose what to do, he examined his options. Hit the cement barrier and risk getting hit from behind or go through the toll and hope the car in front of him was moving away thereby minimizing the risk of injuring someone. He decided to put the car in park–which only slowed the car a little–and go through the toll.
Unfortunately the car in front didn’t move away. Luckily no one was hurt.
When the police officer showed up, he too had a choice. He had to determine whether it was, in fact, an accident and that Bob was telling the truth about his brakes failing, or if he was simply telling a tale to get out of a ticket by swaying responsibility.
The officer chose a third option–he assumed Bob was trying to avoid the $1.25 toll. What made this officer ignore the more likely choices and go for dishonesty of the third kind? Was it Bob’s disheveled look? Did he sound drunk?
I can understand if the officer thought Bob was lying to avoid a ticket. He’s probably seen many people run through tolls. What baffles me is why he would think Bob would run a toll when there was a car at the toll booth. What made him select the most improbable scenario?
The implications for trust are profound. We can influence our own trustworthiness by reducing our self-orientation, and increasing our credibility, reliability and intimacy.
Yet those factors don’t operate in a rational vacuum when we consider whether to trust others. Our upbringing, general experience, specific experiences, psychological makeup and even job responsibilities go into the mix.
Put yourself in the shoes of the police officer. Perhaps something similar happened in the past. Maybe he’s heard so many excuses, that everything sounds like a variation on the theme. Maybe he was just having a difficult day.
Maybe he trusted someone’s story that turned out to be a lie once too often. We want to be trusted, and we would like ourselves and others to be trusting. We have to recognize when our own issues get in the way of trusting others. And hope that our own hard work to be trustworthy will be enough for others to trust us.
What happened to Bob? The tow truck driver confirmed that the brakes failed.
And the officer made my friend pay the toll, just in case.